“Alas! how dreary would be the world if there were no Santa Claus.” –The Sun, 1897
It happened one day when I was nine. My brother Matthew and I were goofing around in the basement when I saw it: the empty package to the totally awesome, all I ever wanted Magic 8 Ball I had gotten from “Santa.” Matthew does a pretty good lip-quivering imitation of when I asked him, “Does that mean Santa’s not real?” He laughed, and then I ran off in tears. (Due to my dramatic delivery, he thought I was kidding, and we’ve since reconciled). I spent the next two hours crying and shouting accusations of dishonesty at my mother. I asked her, “Why did you lie to me?” over and over.
I hardly remember anything from my childhood, but I remember that life-altering day.
There was never supposed to be a Santa for my offspring. This condition was made very clear when I was pregnant with Geraldine, and Nate, not having such strong opinions, agreed. But then, when she was four, something awful happened: Santa propaganda from the ouside world seeped in and made a believer of her, despite our efforts.
Despite my frustration, we played along with both girls for a couple years. But, every time I heard one of them say “Blah blah blah Santa blah blah,” I’d start to cringe. Then, if there was another “Blah blah blah Santa blah blah,” I would wince. A third time would result in twitching. I have a low tolerance for twitching.
During a cringe-wince-twitch episode last week, I signaled Nate that I couldn’t take it anymore and was going to tell the girls the truth. I ignored his “Are you sure this isn’t the worst idea you’ve ever had?” look and sat them down individually to talk about it. I thought it went pretty well. When Nate asked Gigi if she still wanted to pretend about Santa (which was original approach all those years ago) she said, “No, Daddy. Once you know the truth, you can’t go back.”
I prematurely counted it as a win, before the signs that she wasn’t totally okay with it started showing up (e.g., she started reciting names of trusted adults who reportedly still believed in Santa). Then, this weekend, it came to this conversation:
Rhys: Daddy, I still believe in Santa.
Nate: You do?
Gigi: (yelling from the bathtub) Me too.
Nate: (to Gigi) Why?
Gigi: Because I can.
Nate: *facepalm*
Me: (shouting to both of them) Well, I don’t want Santa to get credit for all those Christmas presents I just bought! With my own money!
That one will go down as one of my greatest parenting moments, I’m sure.
The same problem, with a slightly different face, came up again yesterday when I heard Rhys say from the other room that she was going to write a letter to Santa. Then she quickly covered, saying “I mean Grammie! I’m going to write a letter to Grammie!” I asked if she was really going to write to Santa, and she said, in an exaggerated tone, “No, Mama, Santa’s not real.” Then she gave me this placating smile, like she respects the fact that I’m completely jaded, but that she’s privvy to a source of wonder and enchantment that I just don’t understand.
My kids are sending me a clear message: They want me to retract my previous statement so that their imaginations can run wild and enjoy the season to its fullest. Call me stubborn or Grinchy or whatever, but that is one thing I am not going to give them. I respect them, and I believe they possess the emotional intelligence to handle this particular transition from fantasy to reality, without crushing their spirits or ruining Xmas in the process.
I need a new approach, though. Obviously. Yelling about how much money I’ve spent ain’t helping. I have a few ideas, though:
- Look at different Xmas traditions around the world, and holiday traditions of people who don’t celebrate Xmas—not a lot of consistency there.
- Pose annoying logistical questions—how does Santa do it, anyway?
- Play lots and lots of Xmas music to keep the spirit alive!
In the spirit of that last one, the Art of Irreverence will have a ten-part Xmas Music Survival Guide starting tonight at 11:11. Because, even though I’m pushing the Futurama pronunciation of Xmas this year, I really believe in the fun and the joy and the love of this season.
Image credit: “Sad Santa Hat” by Flickr user formatc1, used under a Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 2.0 license.













